All news

1 November 2026

Judge throws out the Justice Department's lawsuit over Alaska's two Dan Sullivans

A federal judge dismissed a DOJ lawsuit that sought to hold up certification of Alaska's Senate race if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses. The DOJ says it will appeal.

Alaska's Senate ballot has two men named Dan Sullivan on it. One is the Republican incumbent. The other is a retired schoolteacher. The Justice Department went to court arguing the second one could confuse voters, and on Sunday a federal judge dismissed its case.

What happened

The DOJ filed suit on October 22, and President Donald Trump has said he ordered it. It asked the court to stop Alaska certifying the result if Sen. Dan S. Sullivan lost, citing possible confusion with Daniel J. Sullivan, the retiree. It also wanted ballots cast for him set aside so federal officials could investigate what voters intended.

Judge Sharon Gleason of the US District Court in Anchorage did not decide whether the second Sullivan was recruited to confuse voters. She ruled that the government lacked legal standing, in part because it offered no workable way to examine individual ballots while keeping the vote secret. Early ballots had already been mixed together, she noted, and running elections is the state's job, not the federal executive branch's. She cited the Supreme Court's Purcell principle, which warns courts against changing election rules at the last minute, and refused to let the DOJ amend its complaint again.

The DOJ said the case was dismissed on procedural grounds and that the court had not disputed its view that the second Sullivan was a frivolous candidate. It filed notice that it will appeal to the 9th Circuit. Trump called the situation voter fraud and said Democratic nominee Mary Peltola should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted.

A New York Times report said aides to Peltola and to the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee were involved in recruiting the retiree. Both deny any role in his campaign. Peltola's campaign called the lawsuit baseless, and the DSCC called the ruling "a victory for democracy." Sen. Sullivan said on CNN that he would accept the result if he lost, while accusing his opponents of cheating.

State officials say the ballot is designed to avoid mix-ups: the senator is listed as Dan S. Sullivan, marked as incumbent and registered Republican, while the other is listed as Daniel J. Sullivan with nothing beside his name.

Why it matters

Republicans hold a narrow Senate majority, and Alaska is one of several races that will decide who controls it. Senate control shapes tax, spending and regulation policy, which markets watch closely. A fight over certifying a result could also stretch out uncertainty about that control after Election Day.

What to watch

  • The DOJ's appeal to the 9th Circuit.
  • The ranked-choice count, including where second choices on Daniel J. Sullivan and Gerald Heikes ballots go.
  • Ongoing criminal and civil investigations the US Attorney for Alaska has said are under way.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Judge dismisses Alaska Senate election lawsuit; DOJ vows appeal. Facts, not advice.

More news