All news

28 September 2026

Justice Alito steps out of the Exxon climate case, raising the odds of a 4-4 tie

Samuel Alito reversed course and will sit out a Supreme Court case over whether Boulder, Colorado, can sue Exxon Mobil and Suncor for climate damages. Arguments are on October 5.

One Supreme Court justice just changed the math on a case worth watching if you own oil stocks. Samuel Alito has recused himself, meaning he will not take part, from a climate lawsuit against Exxon Mobil and Canadian oil producer Suncor Energy, a week before the court hears it.

What happened

The city of Boulder, Colorado, and its surrounding county sued the two companies, asking them to pay for local harm the plaintiffs blame on climate change. The oil companies tried to get the case thrown out. A Colorado trial court said no, and the Colorado Supreme Court agreed, clearing the way for a trial.

The US Supreme Court took the appeal to answer one question: does federal law block this kind of claim, brought under state law, over damage allegedly caused by greenhouse gas emissions? Oral arguments are set for October 5.

Environmental groups had asked Alito to step aside because he owns shares in oil companies. In May a court spokeswoman said he would stay on, noting he held no financial interest in any party in the case and that the court's lawyers had told him recusal was not required. On Monday the court's clerk told the lawyers that Alito would no longer participate. No reason was given in the letter.

Why it matters

Alito is one of the court's six conservative justices. With him out, eight justices remain, which makes a 4-4 tie possible. A tie does not create a national rule; it simply leaves the lower court's decision in place. Here that would mean Boulder's case goes on toward a trial in Colorado.

That matters beyond one city. Many other states and cities have filed similar climate suits against oil companies. A clear ruling for the companies could shut many of them down. A tie would settle nothing and leave oil producers facing drawn-out litigation, and the legal bills and uncertainty that come with it.

For scale, Exxon is worth about $667 billion on the stock market and earned about $32.8 billion over the last twelve months, according to Noorult's data. Suncor is worth about $82 billion. Any damages from this one case are unknown, but the bigger question for investors is how many copycat suits survive.

What to watch

  • The October 5 arguments, and which way the remaining justices seem to lean.
  • Whether the eventual decision comes out as a tie or a real majority.
  • How other climate suits against oil companies move while this one is pending.

Company figures are on Noorult's pages for Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy.

The companies in this story

Based on reporting by CNBC: Supreme Court Justice Alito recuses from climate change case. Facts, not advice.

More news