24 October 2026
A former hedge fund insider says home stock pickers face Wall Street's machines
Victor Haghani of Elm Wealth told CNBC that most at-home investors struggle to beat the market, while RBC's Valerie Grimba argued that more fund choice is a good thing.
Should regular investors try to pick winning stocks, or just buy the whole market? Two guests on CNBC's "ETF Edge" this week gave different answers, and the debate is one of the oldest in investing.
What happened
Victor Haghani, founder and chief investment officer of Elm Wealth, said retail investors chasing the market with single stocks and complicated exchange-traded funds (ETFs, funds that trade on an exchange like a share) might do better in broad index funds. Haghani was a founding partner of Long-Term Capital Management, the hedge fund whose 1998 collapse led to a Fed-organized rescue by Wall Street banks.
His main worry is human nature. He pointed to extrapolation bias: the habit of assuming whatever just happened will keep happening. He also said the other side of a home investor's trade is often a giant trading firm such as Citadel, Jane Street or Hudson River Trading, which can spend something like $1 billion a year on technology.
Valerie Grimba, director of global ETF strategy at RBC Capital Markets, was more upbeat on newer products. She said concentrated funds holding 10 to 15 stocks let people back a theme without having to guess which single company wins, and that funds built on derivatives (contracts whose value comes from another asset, like options) can be used to generate income. Her condition: investors should be able to explain to a friend what is inside the fund.
Index funds vs stock picking, in plain English
An index fund buys every company in a list such as the S&P 500, the 500 large US companies most people mean by "the market". It does not try to win; it tries to match the market, and because nobody is paid to choose stocks, fees are usually tiny.
Stock picking means choosing a handful of companies in the hope of doing better than the market. That extra return is what Wall Street calls alpha. The catch is that every share bought is sold by someone else, so one side's win is the other side's miss before costs. Long-running studies, such as S&P's SPIVA reports, have found that most professional fund managers trail their benchmark index over long periods.
Why it matters
The fund menu keeps growing, from single-theme ETFs to options-income funds. Grimba stressed understanding what is inside a fund, while Haghani's firm puts low costs first. Picking stocks is not banned by math, but it is a competition, and Haghani's point is that the competition is unusually well funded. Which approach suits any one person depends on their own goals, time and costs.
Based on reporting by CNBC: Stock picking could hurt investors, warns former hedge fund manager. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion