All news

2 November 2026

Judge throws out DOJ suit seeking Harvard's admissions data, on procedural grounds

A federal judge in Boston dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit to force Harvard to hand over applicant-level admissions records, saying the department skipped required steps.

The Justice Department wanted a court to make Harvard University hand over years of records on individual applicants, to see whether race still plays a part in who gets in. On Monday, US District Judge Myong Joun in Boston dismissed that lawsuit. He was careful to say the ruling is about process, not about whether Harvard did anything wrong.

What happened

The DOJ filed the case in February. It argued Harvard was not cooperating with investigations into whether the school follows the Supreme Court's 2023 decision, in a case involving Harvard, that ended race-conscious admissions. The government said it needed applicant-level data to check compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the law that bans racial discrimination in education programs that get federal money.

Judge Joun, who was appointed by President Biden, agreed with Harvard that the department went to court too early. Before suing, the law requires steps meant to get a school to comply voluntarily. He found the complaint did not say the DOJ had warned Harvard it would sue, or spelled out exactly what Harvard had failed to do.

The judge also said the DOJ could bring a similar case again once it completes those steps, and that he was not deciding whether the government can eventually get the data.

What each side says

The administration says it needs the data to make sure Harvard is following civil rights law, and Trump has accused the school of behaving badly for a long time. Harvard's lawyers argue the case was retaliation for the school refusing demands to change its governance, hiring and academic programs. They point to timing: the suit came after President Trump said in early February he was ending settlement talks and wanted $1 billion in damages from the university. Neither side commented right away on Monday's ruling.

Harvard released figures last week showing Black undergraduate enrollment fell for a third straight year since the 2023 ruling, to 9.3% of the class of 2030 from 11.5% the year before.

Why it matters

Harvard has been a top target of the administration's push to use federal funding and government power to force changes at universities. The school has already won rulings from other judges blocking efforts to cut more than $2 billion in grants and to stop it from hosting international students. Federal grants pay for a lot of university research, so the outcome of these cases matters well beyond one campus.

What to watch

  • Whether the DOJ takes the extra administrative steps and refiles.
  • Any appeals in Harvard's other cases with the administration.
  • Whether talks on a wider settlement between Harvard and the White House restart.

Based on reporting by CNBC: U.S. judge dismisses Trump administration’s Harvard admissions probe case. Facts, not advice.

More news