All news

2 October 2026

The IRS draws a line under a tax trick that turned stock piles into brand-new ETFs

Treasury and the IRS issued new guidance saying some Section 351 ETF conversions, used by wealthy investors to defer capital gains tax, don't work under current law.

Imagine you own a big pile of stock that has soared in value. Sell it and you owe capital gains tax, the tax on the profit from selling something for more than you paid. A strategy popular with very wealthy investors tried to get around that by pouring those shares into a freshly made ETF. This week the US Treasury and the IRS said some versions of that move don't hold up.

What happened

The rules involved sit in Section 351 of the tax code. In general, it lets you hand property to a corporation in exchange for its shares without that counting as a sale, so no gain is taxed at that point. There are conditions: for a portfolio of securities, no single holding can be more than 25% of the value, and the five biggest can't top 50% combined.

The authorities put out two documents. A revenue ruling, which is the IRS's official reading of one specific set of facts, covers a case where an investor seeded a new ETF, the fund quickly paid the shares back out, and the investor walked away with a very different portfolio without ever paying tax on the old gains. A broader notice flags transactions where the ETF is just a pass-through for dodging tax, and treats moves made shortly after the shares go in as suspect. It doesn't say how soon is too soon.

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said of these conversions that "they don't work under existing law." The notice also says it takes no view on ETFs seeded with assets that fit the fund's strategy and that the fund intends to keep.

Why it matters

This was never a mass-market tactic. Setting up an ETF can cost $200,000 to $300,000, so it has mostly been used by people with very large stock positions. But the sums add up: a Bloomberg analysis cited by CNBC counted $22 billion in ETFs created for this purpose, deferring up to $6.5 billion in gains, with activity picking up sharply since 2024.

Ordinary ETF investors aren't the target. Big funds swap baskets of securities for fund shares every day without triggering tax, which is a core reason ETFs are known for tax efficiency, and nothing here goes after that machinery. The notice does say the IRS is also looking at related setups, including transfers through partnerships and ETFs built on options-based box spread strategies that defer gains.

What to watch

  • Public comments on the notice, which are due by October 28.
  • Follow-up guidance spelling out how quickly after a contribution a payout becomes a problem.
  • Whether Congress chooses to change how ETFs are taxed when they hand out appreciated securities.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Treasury Sec. Bessent, IRS crack down on ETF strategy the wealthy are using to avoid capital gains taxes. Facts, not advice.

More news