2 November 2026
Judge throws out case against two ex-FBI officials over Hunter Biden testimony
A federal magistrate judge dismissed charges that two former FBI officials lied to Congress, saying prosecutors lacked probable cause. The Justice Department says it disagrees.
Ten days after the Justice Department charged two former FBI officials with lying to Congress, a federal judge in Washington threw the case out. The officials, Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides, had been accused of giving false testimony in 2023 about investigations into Hunter Biden, the son of former President Joe Biden.
What happened
At a hearing on Monday, Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui ruled that the government had not shown probable cause, the basic legal standard of having enough evidence to justify a charge. According to MS NOW, he said prosecutors had not presented evidence that the officials knowingly lied to the House Judiciary Committee.
Several outlets reported that the judge criticized the department sharply. He said the case had been rushed ahead of the midterm elections and that the situation "cannot be described as anything other than weaponization." He also apologized to the government's own lawyers, saying it was unfair they had been handed the case.
The Justice Department told CNBC it disagrees with the decision and is weighing its options, and said its actions are guided by facts, evidence and the law rather than politics. Lawyers for both former officials welcomed the ruling. Benavides's lawyer said he hopes prosecutors will not try to revive the case through a grand jury.
How the case was brought
The way the charges were filed was part of the dispute. Prosecutors usually bring serious federal charges through an indictment, which a grand jury of citizens votes on in private. Here, they used a criminal complaint instead, which needs only a judge's signature and is typically used when prosecutors must move fast, such as to get an arrest warrant. The alleged false statements dated back to 2023.
Faruqui had already called that choice unusual. Last week he refused to approve an updated complaint that would have added an obstruction charge, and at a hearing he asked prosecutors why they had changed how they charge cases for this one.
What to watch
- Whether the Justice Department appeals or seeks an indictment from a grand jury.
- Any further court filings from the two former officials' lawyers.
Based on reporting by CNBC: Judge tosses DOJ case against ex-FBI officials accused of lying about Hunter Biden probe. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion