All news

28 September 2026

A judge strikes down FEMA's plan to tie anti-terror money to election changes

A federal judge threw out a FEMA rule that would have held back 20% of states' counterterrorism grants unless they changed how they run elections, saying the agency overstepped its authority.

A federal judge in Washington has scrapped a Trump administration rule that tied counterterrorism money for states to changes in how they run elections. Judge Amir Ali ruled on Monday that the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), part of the Department of Homeland Security, went beyond what Congress allowed it to do.

What happened

FEMA issued the rule in June. It told states, and the big cities it counts as high-risk urban areas, to adopt a list of election changes or lose 20% of their share of federal counterterrorism grants. The list included:

  • A plan to move from voting machines that record votes as bar codes or QR codes to paper ballots marked by hand.
  • A manual audit of 5% of ballots after each election, under federal guidelines.
  • Checking that the number of people who voted matches the number of ballots cast.
  • Verifying the US citizenship of everyone on the voter rolls, plus poll workers, election officials and voting-system vendors.

In August, two Texas counties, a county in Tennessee and the city of Columbus, Ohio, sued. The Brennan Center for Justice at New York University, which represents some of them, said the money at stake added up to tens of millions of dollars.

Judge Ali set the rule aside, a step known as vacating it. He wrote that the conditions dealt with routine election administration, that states would have to pay for them themselves, and that FEMA never showed how they would make anyone safer from terrorism. CNBC asked the Justice Department, which argued the case for the government, for comment.

Why it matters

The ruling is about who controls elections. The Constitution largely leaves running them to the states, with Congress able to set some rules. Using grant money as leverage is a way for a federal agency to push changes it cannot simply order. Courts have now pushed back on that approach here, and the Brennan Center says courts have blocked most of the administration's earlier attempts to shape election rules.

It also matters for city budgets. Counterterrorism grants pay for things like police equipment, training and emergency planning. Losing a fifth of that money would have forced local officials to choose between the election changes and their security spending.

What to watch

  • Whether the administration appeals the ruling to a higher court.
  • Whether FEMA tries a narrower rule that ties the conditions more closely to terrorism risk.
  • How states handle their grant plans while the legal fight continues.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Judge voids linking FEMA counterterrorism funds to election rule changes. Facts, not advice.

More news