All news

26 September 2026

Natural diamonds have lost half their value in five years as lab-grown stones take over

The average 1-carat natural diamond now sells for about $3,898, down 51% from 2021, squeezed by a glut of mined stones and cheaper lab-grown rivals.

Diamonds are forever, but their prices are not. A typical 1-carat natural diamond now sells for about $3,898, down 51% from an average of $8,007 in 2021, according to diamond trading platform Rapaport Group. The Diamond Standard Index, which tracks investment-grade stones, hit its lowest level ever in early August and was only just above that this week.

What happened

Two forces are pushing prices down. First, too much supply: mines produced heavily during Covid, leaving a large pile of unsold stones in 2023 and 2024. Second, lab-grown diamonds. These are real diamonds, chemically and physically the same as mined ones, made by applying heat and pressure to carbon above ground. You cannot tell them apart by eye, but you can by price.

A CNBC search found a lab stone with a given cut, color and clarity listed for about $450 on Brilliant Earth's marketplace, while a natural stone with the same specs cost $2,800 to $3,200. Lab-grown gems can be up to 90% cheaper. Shoppers have noticed: lab-grown center stones were in 61% of engagement rings sold in 2025, according to The Knot's 2026 Real Weddings Study.

Miners are trying to shrink supply. De Beers, owned by Anglo American, said in July it would pause its flagship Venetia mine in South Africa for more than two years, and at least two other mines have announced permanent closures this year. Diamond Standard's CEO, Cormac Kinney, told CNBC he sees wholesale prices for some qualities rising again.

Why it matters

The shift is changing the math for jewelry retailers. Industry data from Gordon Brothers shows lab-grown stones generally earn gross margins of 60% to 65%, compared with 40% to 45% for natural diamonds. Signet Jewelers, owner of Kay and Zales, has been adding lab-grown stones to simple pieces such as tennis bracelets. Its shares are up about 21% this year, including a roughly 24% one-day jump on September 9 after it raised its annual profit forecast. Signet is worth about $3.9 billion on the stock market, according to Noorult data.

For anyone who thinks of a diamond as a store of value, the story is harsher. There is no standard spot market for diamonds because no two stones are alike, a diamond can sit on the resale market for over a year, and stones often resell for less than half their original retail price.

What to watch

  • Whether mine shutdowns lift natural diamond prices off their lows.
  • The lab-grown diamond market, which Fortune Business Insights projects will reach nearly $92 billion by 2034, up from about $29.5 billion in 2025.
  • Signet's next results, and how much of its sales come from lab-grown pieces.

Signet's financials are on its Noorult company page.

The companies in this story

Based on reporting by CNBC: What's behind the fall of diamond prices to record lows. Facts, not advice.

More news