All news

8 October 2026

The NFL asks the Supreme Court to treat sports prediction contracts as gambling

In a brief backing New Jersey against Kalshi, the NFL argued that states, not federal commodity regulators, should police sports prediction markets.

Prediction markets let people buy contracts that pay out if something happens, such as a team winning on Sunday. Their legal status is one of the biggest open questions in finance and sport, and the National Football League has now taken its view straight to the Supreme Court.

What happened

The NFL filed an amicus brief, a legal argument from an outside party, supporting New Jersey regulators in their dispute with Kalshi, one of the biggest prediction market platforms. Kalshi has argued in court that sports event contracts are financial swaps, so only the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) should regulate them. The NFL argues they are effectively gambling, which states have long controlled.

Federal appeals courts have disagreed with each other on whether states can enforce their gambling laws against these platforms, which is the kind of split the Supreme Court is often asked to settle. The league framed its argument around state power, asking what part of the Constitution would let Congress override states on gambling that happens inside their borders.

Why the NFL cares

Football is a giant slice of this market. On the opening Sunday of the season, the league said, NFL contracts drew $1.8 billion of prediction market trading, more than half of all volume that day.

The league says it is not against prediction markets as such. Its worries are specific:

  • Contracts on single plays that one player could rig, such as a kicker missing a field goal on purpose or a receiver dropping a pass.
  • Bets tied to injuries, refereeing or other news that insiders might know first.
  • Age limits: the NFL wants a minimum of 21, as most states require for sports betting, while Kalshi accepts customers from 18.

The NFL told CNBC that, given the CFTC's limited resources, the job is better left to the states. It also bans prediction platforms from advertising with it, and Commissioner Roger Goodell said in September that the league is happy to be patient rather than first.

Not every league agrees

Other sports have chosen to partner up. The NHL has deals with both Kalshi and Polymarket, while Major League Baseball, Major League Soccer and UFC have signed with Polymarket. The NFL, NBA and PGA have no such partnerships.

For investors, the outcome matters beyond sport. Whether these contracts are swaps under federal rules or bets under 50 sets of state laws will shape how big the industry can grow, who can use it, and which companies can list products tied to it. CNBC noted it has a commercial relationship with Kalshi, including a minority investment.

Based on reporting by CNBC: NFL tells Supreme Court prediction markets are gambling and should be regulated by the states. Facts, not advice.

More news