30 September 2026
Prediction markets brag about trading volume. Some experts doubt the numbers.
Kalshi and Polymarket deny wash trading, but odd volume patterns on some contracts have outside experts asking how much of the activity is real.
Prediction markets let people trade contracts on whether something will happen, like an election result or a central bank decision. Two of the biggest, Kalshi and Polymarket, use huge trading volumes to show they are growing fast. Now some observers are asking whether parts of that volume is real demand.
What happened
On September 20, a user on X pointed out a strange pattern in Kalshi's perpetual futures for ether (a contract that tracks a price with no expiry date). CNBC found that nearly half of that day's dollar volume came from trades sized between $5,495 and $5,505. The worry is wash trading, where traders buy and sell among themselves to fake activity. Kalshi says it checked and found hundreds of different users behind the trades, and that they were likely speculators exploiting small price lags (arbitrage). The experts CNBC spoke to mostly agreed it probably was not wash trading.
Their concern is different. Kalshi's volume on bitcoin and ether perpetuals is about 42 and 66 times its open interest, meaning the money actually held in open positions. On Polymarket's ether perpetuals the ratio is about three-quarters, and on Hyperliquid it is about one third. Kalshi says it has offered lower leverage and operates under U.S. rules, so the comparison is unfair. One critic, finance professor Rajiv Sethi, pointed to fee rebates that let traders profit consistently, while saying he was not blaming wash trading.
On Polymarket's international exchange, which U.S. regulators do not oversee, long-shot contracts often trade more than favorites. One Ethiopian prime minister market had almost $56 million traded on a candidate below 3%, against about $170,000 on the winner at 98%. Polymarket says skilled traders correcting mispricings explain it. Some observers link it to hopes of a token giveaway, which Polymarket declined to comment on.
Why it matters
Polymarket is reportedly raising money at a valuation above $20 billion, and Kalshi is reportedly in talks at $40 billion. Both are reported to be exploring a stock market listing as soon as next year. Volume is the headline number behind those valuations. A finance professor wrote that if a material share of volume is manufactured, it could overstate real demand.
CNBC also reported that The Wall Street Journal said the CFTC, the U.S. derivatives regulator, is looking at the Kalshi ether trades. CNBC could not verify that, and the agency would not confirm it. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said on CNBC the agency has zero tolerance for manipulative trading.
What to watch
- Any CFTC action or public statement on the Kalshi ether contract.
- Whether Polymarket's Ethiopian contract settles on October 5, when the new government is due to be sworn in.
- Whether either company changes its fee rebates or incentives.
Disclosure from the source: CNBC has a commercial relationship with Kalshi, including a minority investment.
Based on reporting by CNBC: Kalshi, Polymarket trading volumes on some products raises questions amid massive growth. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion