All news

30 September 2026

Trade court hears challenge to tariffs covering 99.4% of US imports

Small businesses and Democratic-led states argue the new Section 301 tariffs on 86 countries are a pretext for rebuilding tariffs the Supreme Court struck down.

A three-judge panel at the US Court of International Trade in Manhattan heard arguments on Wednesday in the third court fight in under two years over President Donald Trump's broad tariffs. A tariff is a tax on imported goods, usually paid first by the company bringing them in.

What happened

The tariffs at issue are 10% or 12.5% levies on products from 86 countries, which together account for 99.4% of US imports. The administration says it imposed them because those countries did not do enough to stop trade in goods made with forced labor. It used Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, which allows action against unfair foreign trade practices.

The challengers, which include small businesses and states led by Democrats, say the forced-labor rationale is a pretext. Their attorney, Pratik Shah, argued the law requires findings that each country's practices are unreasonable and burden US commerce, and that there were no country-specific findings. One judge asked what difference it makes if the government has other motives too.

Justice Department attorneys say the US Trade Representative followed the law.

How we got here

The Supreme Court struck down Trump's April 2025 "reciprocal" tariffs in February, and the government had to refund more than $100 billion. That same day Trump announced a worldwide 10% tariff under Section 122 of the same 1974 law, which could last only 150 days. The trade court ruled against those tariffs, but an appeals court paused the ruling and they stayed in place until they expired in July. The Section 301 duties began right after.

Why it matters

Tariffs raise costs for importers, and the refund figure shows how large the money involved can be if a court rules against them. A ruling against these tariffs would not automatically end them, since earlier decisions were paused or appealed, but it would add to uncertainty for companies that buy from abroad.

Trump told Fox News in late July that the 301 tariffs serve the same purpose as the ones the Supreme Court struck down. The challengers' lawyers say that remark supports their case.

What to watch

  • The panel's ruling, which the article says has not yet been issued.
  • Whether an appeals court pauses any decision, as happened before.
  • Any refund rules if the tariffs are struck down.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Trump's latest global tariffs face trade court challenge. Facts, not advice.

More news