All news

25 September 2026

Shale pioneer Scott Sheffield turns on Exxon over the deal that made him richer

The former Pioneer Natural Resources boss says Exxon worked against him during the FTC review of its $60 billion takeover. Exxon calls the deal a huge success.

Two years after selling his company to ExxonMobil, Scott Sheffield is still one of Exxon's biggest individual shareholders. He is also one of its loudest critics. In an interview with the FT and in a forthcoming autobiography, the shale oil veteran accuses Exxon of undermining him while regulators reviewed the deal.

What happened

Exxon bought Sheffield's Pioneer Natural Resources in 2024 for $60 billion. The FT reported in 2023 that Sheffield would receive $29 million from the sale plus about $150 million in Exxon stock for his Pioneer shares. He says the deal was right for shareholders because it gave them a 19% premium, meaning Exxon paid 19% more than Pioneer's market price.

The sore point is what came with it. The Federal Trade Commission, the US agency that polices mergers and competition, approved the deal only on the condition that Sheffield could not join Exxon's board. That followed an investigation in which the FTC alleged he had colluded with OPEC, the group of big oil-producing countries, to push up oil prices.

In his book, Sheffield claims Exxon was working with the FTC, leaking damaging stories to the media and trying to stop a lobbying group from working for him. He told the FT that Exxon CEO Darren Woods broke personal assurances, and that he would not want a seat on what he called Exxon's "patsy board" now anyway. Woods, in a statement through Exxon, said the industry had not seen a more successful merger in a long time.

Why it matters

Whatever the personal fallout, the numbers have been kind to Exxon. Pioneer gave it a dominant position in the Permian Basin, the largest US oilfield, two years before the war with Iran disrupted the Strait of Hormuz and sent oil prices up this year. Exxon is now worth about $667 billion and earned about $33 billion over the last twelve months, according to Noorult data. Its shares have delivered a total return of about 44% over the past year.

The FT notes the Pioneer deal is one of the few oil mergers in recent decades to have worked out well for shareholders. That makes Sheffield's complaints a rare public look at how founders can lose control of the story once they sell.

What to watch

  • The release of Sheffield's autobiography and any response from Exxon or the FTC.
  • Exxon's Permian output as oil prices react to the war.

Exxon's full financials are on its Noorult company page.

The companies in this story

Based on reporting by the Financial Times: The shale wildcatter lambasting Exxon. Facts, not advice.

More news