All news

25 September 2026

Second appeals court says states can treat Kalshi's sports contracts as gambling

The 6th Circuit ruled unanimously that Ohio and Tennessee can apply their gambling laws to Kalshi's sports event contracts, deepening a split that may end at the Supreme Court.

Is betting on a football game through a prediction market a financial trade or a sports bet? On Friday a second federal appeals court said states get to treat it like a bet, a major setback for platforms like Kalshi.

What happened

A three-judge panel of the 6th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that Ohio and Tennessee can apply their state gambling laws to Kalshi's sports-related event contracts, which pay out depending on whether something happens, such as a team winning.

Kalshi argues these contracts are swaps, a type of financial derivative that federal law puts under the exclusive control of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the national regulator for futures and derivatives. The court disagreed on two fronts. It said Kalshi had not shown its sports contracts meet the legal definition of a swap. And even if they did, the judges said, federal commodities law does not override state gambling laws.

The ruling overturns a Tennessee federal court decision that had sided with Kalshi, and backs an Ohio federal court that had sided with the state.

Tennessee's attorney general welcomed the decision, saying Kalshi had tried to avoid the rules and taxes that apply to sports betting. Kalshi said it disagreed and that the ruling shows why "a state-by-state patchwork doesn't work."

Why it matters

Prediction markets offer sports contracts nationwide on the basis that they fall under federal rules, not state betting licenses. If states can regulate them as gambling, platforms may face 50 different sets of rules, licenses and taxes, much like traditional sportsbooks do.

The courts are now split. The 3rd Circuit ruled in April that the CFTC has exclusive power over all swaps, siding against New Jersey. The 9th Circuit ruled last month that Nevada can regulate sports event contracts. Now the 6th Circuit has joined the 9th. The CFTC itself has sued nine states to defend its claim to exclusive authority.

When federal appeals courts disagree on the same legal question, the Supreme Court often steps in to settle it. Earlier this month New Jersey asked the Supreme Court to review its loss, though it is not clear whether the justices will take the case now or wait for more circuits to rule.

One disclosure worth knowing: CNBC, which reported the story, has a commercial relationship with Kalshi that includes a minority investment.

What to watch

  • Whether the Supreme Court agrees to hear New Jersey's petition.
  • Rulings from other appeals courts in the CFTC's lawsuits against states.
  • How Ohio and Tennessee move to enforce their gambling laws after the ruling.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Appeals court rules states can regulate sports prediction markets. Facts, not advice.

More news