All news

28 September 2026

Almost half the S&P 500 is moving the opposite way to the S&P 500

About 45% of S&P 500 stocks now have a negative three-month beta, Goldman Sachs says, a sign of how few giant stocks are carrying the index.

When the S&P 500 goes up, you would expect most of the stocks inside it to go up too. Lately that is not what is happening. According to a note from Goldman Sachs, about 45% of the index's members have recently tended to move in the opposite direction to the index itself.

What happened

The measure behind this is beta, which tracks how a stock moves compared with the whole market. A beta of 1 means it moves in step; a negative beta means it has been going down when the market goes up, and up when it goes down. Goldman found about 45% of S&P 500 stocks with a negative beta over the past three months. CNBC's own count, using weekly returns, came in close: nearly 40% over three months and 17% over one year.

Other signals point the same way. Last Monday the S&P 500 rose 1.5%, yet 30 of its stocks hit 52-week lows while only 7 hit 52-week highs. Jason Goepfert of SentimenTrader said the last time the index gained at least 1%, sat within 1% of a record, and still had more new lows than new highs was December 1999, just before the dot-com peak.

Why it matters

The main cause is concentration. The S&P 500 weights companies by size, so a handful of mega-cap tech names carry a huge share of it. If those few do well, the index can climb even while hundreds of smaller members slide. LPL Financial's Adam Turnquist pointed to unusually low correlation between stocks, meaning they are moving for different reasons at different times, which also makes the index look calmer than the stocks inside it.

Energy is a second driver. Higher oil prices have pushed energy stocks up on days when the rest of the market falls. Evercore ISI counted 115 S&P 500 stocks with a negative six-month beta, weighted toward energy, utilities and consumer staples, and described energy as acting like insurance against a sell-off.

For an ordinary index-fund investor, the takeaway is that a record-high S&P 500 can hide a lot of losers. Your fund's return depends heavily on a few very large companies.

Does 1999 mean a crash is coming? The strategists CNBC spoke to said no. Turnquist and WisdomTree's Bradley Krom both argued today's leaders are mature, profitable businesses, unlike many dot-com stars. "It is not the same market environment now versus 2000," Krom said.

What to watch

  • Whether gains spread beyond AI and big tech, which Turnquist said would likely shrink the negative-beta count.
  • Oil prices, which keep pulling energy stocks away from the rest of the market.
  • Krom's expectation that these extreme readings eventually fade back toward normal.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Nearly half the S&P 500 are at cross purposes with the rest of the market. Facts, not advice.

More news