All news

2 November 2026

Supreme Court lets California count 20,000 disputed mail ballots on the eve of the midterms

The justices turned down a Justice Department request to pause the count of mail ballots from voters it said may not be citizens, without explanation or noted dissent.

On Monday evening, the night before Election Day, the Supreme Court said no to the Justice Department. The DOJ had asked the court to temporarily stop California from counting mail-in ballots cast by about 20,000 voters it believes may not be US citizens. The court's answer was a single sentence, with no reasons given and no dissents noted.

What happened

The case moved fast. The DOJ sued California in federal court in Los Angeles on October 15, asking that ballots from people on a Department of Homeland Security list be held back until their citizenship could be checked. Non-citizens are not allowed to vote in federal elections.

Judge David Carter refused that request on October 28, writing that the case was about every citizen's right to vote. On October 30 a three-judge appeals panel in the 9th Circuit upheld him 2-1, saying there was a real risk that eligible voters would lose their votes. The two judges in the majority were appointed by President Trump and President Biden.

Solicitor General D. John Sauer, who argues for the government at the Supreme Court, said the US would likely win on the merits, and that once disputed ballots are mixed in with valid ones they cannot be pulled back out. California Attorney General Rob Bonta called the request a "Hail Mary" and noted the court ruled without even asking California to respond, which he said had not happened since 2018.

In a related California case, a DOJ lawyer acknowledged in court that the lists of suspected non-citizens had a high error rate, while arguing that the errors are exactly why the rolls need checking, according to a report cited by CNBC.

Why it matters

Tuesday's midterm elections decide which party controls the House and the Senate, and with it the path for taxes, spending and regulation over the next two years. Fights over which ballots count can matter in close races, and California is the country's most populous state. For now, the disputed ballots will be counted along with the rest.

It is not the only election case. A federal judge on Sunday threw out a separate DOJ suit over how Alaska certifies its Senate result, and the department is appealing that ruling.

What to watch

  • How long California's count takes; the state usually needs days or weeks to finish counting mail ballots.
  • The DOJ's appeal in the Alaska Senate certification case.
  • Whether other election lawsuits reach the courts after polls close.

Based on reporting by CNBC: Supreme Court rejects DOJ’s bid to block California from counting disputed ballots. Facts, not advice.

More news