31 October 2026
Judge again tosses Trump's $10 billion WSJ suit and bars him from refiling it
A federal judge in Miami dismissed with prejudice President Trump's amended defamation case against Rupert Murdoch and the Journal over its Epstein birthday letter story. Trump plans to appeal.
A federal judge has dismissed, for the second time, President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against Rupert Murdoch and The Wall Street Journal. This time the dismissal is with prejudice, which means Trump cannot file the same claims against them again in federal court. His legal team says he will appeal.
What happened
The case is about a Journal article from July 2025. It reported that a letter bearing Trump's signature was part of an album of birthday letters gathered for Jeffrey Epstein's 50th birthday in 2003. Trump has firmly denied writing the letter and sued the paper, Murdoch and others for defamation, meaning false statements that damage someone's reputation.
Judge Darrin Gayles first dismissed the suit in April but let Trump file an amended version to fix its legal problems. On Saturday, in a 20-page ruling, he dismissed that version too. He found Trump had again failed to plausibly show actual malice. Under Supreme Court precedent, a public figure suing for defamation must show the publisher knew a statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for whether it was true. The judge said the Journal had looked into the story carefully and in depth, and rejected the argument that the paper should not have published once Trump denied the letter was his, saying that would let public figures block unfavorable coverage in a way that conflicts with the First Amendment.
The ruling did not decide whether Trump wrote the letter. A Dow Jones spokesperson said the company was pleased with the decision. A spokesman for Trump's legal team said the president would keep pressing the case and would "hold those who mislead the American People" accountable.
Why it matters
The Journal is owned by Dow Jones, part of News Corp, the publicly traded company Murdoch controls. The amount Trump sought was large next to the company itself. News Corp's stock market value was about $16.4 billion as of October 30, according to Noorult data, so $10 billion would have been roughly three-fifths of it. Over the last twelve months News Corp earned about $573 million of net income on $9.0 billion of revenue, according to its filings.
The case is one of several between Trump and media companies. Separately, a different federal judge in Miami ordered Trump on October 22 to sit for a deposition, sworn questioning by the other side's lawyers, by December 11 in his $10 billion defamation suit against the BBC.
What to watch
- Trump's appeal, which would go to the federal appeals court that covers Florida.
- The BBC case and the December 11 deposition deadline.
The companies in this story
Based on reporting by CNBC: Trump defamation suit against Murdoch, WSJ over Epstein letter dismissed with prejudice. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion