25 September 2026
Putting one child in charge of the family trust is a top cause of inheritance fights
A study of 640 contested trust cases found siblings suing a sibling-trustee is common, cases average 481 days, and mediation sharply raises the odds of settling.
Trusts are supposed to make passing on money quiet and simple. A new study suggests one common setup does the opposite. Researchers looked at 640 contested trust cases and found that naming one child to run a family trust that also benefits their siblings is a reliable way to end up in court.
What happened
A trust is a legal arrangement where a trustee manages money or property on behalf of beneficiaries, the people who get it. The study, published this month in the Washington University Law Review by law professors Christopher Ryan, Reid Weisbord and David Horton, examined cases due to come before San Francisco Superior Court from 2014 to 2020. Studies like this are rare because trust fights usually stay private.
Key findings:
- Nearly a quarter of disputes involved one family beneficiary suing another who was also the trustee, often siblings.
- In 74% of cases the trustee was accused of misconduct, such as failing to act carefully or loyally.
- In nearly a third, beneficiaries asked for a detailed accounting of the trust's money.
- The average case lasted 481 days, settled cases included.
- Almost all involved revocable trusts, a popular tool for avoiding probate, the court process for settling a will.
Ryan told CNBC the one-child-in-charge setup can mix normal sibling rivalry with a real power imbalance. If one child decides when the others get paid, old feelings of favoritism can flare up.
Why it matters
Many families use trusts precisely to avoid the time and cost of probate. This research shows they can still lead to long, expensive fights, often driven more by emotion than money. When cases went to a full trial instead of being decided on paperwork and arguments, challengers' chances of winning or settling fell by 48 percentage points.
The encouraging news is that many fights end in a deal: the authors estimate as many as three-quarters of petitions settled. Mediation, where a neutral third party helps both sides negotiate, made a big difference: 85% of mediated cases settled, versus 47% without it.
What the authors suggest
- Explain estate-planning choices to heirs while you are still alive, to surface conflict early.
- Consider an independent or professional trustee instead of one family member.
- Do not count on no-contest clauses, which cut out heirs who sue; how well they work depends on the state.
As Horton put it: "Death brings out strong emotions."
Based on reporting by CNBC: Study reveals estate-planning choices likely to cause conflict. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion