21 October 2026
Old chat logs put Webull's promise about US customer data under the microscope
A House committee released 2021 work messages it says show a Webull employee in China discussing a US customer's account. Webull says US data stays in the US.
Webull, the trading app with 28 million users, has spent two weeks insisting that information about its American customers never leaves American hands. Now the House Select Committee on China, a bipartisan group of lawmakers, has released internal chat messages it says tell a different story.
What happened
The messages date to 2021 and were sent over Microsoft Teams. One side is Brendan Fuller, a manager at Webull's US brokerage. The other is an employee named Zhenghan Wang. The committee says Wang was probably in China at the time, because the timestamps line up with a Beijing working day and his software was set to translate the chat into simplified Chinese.
In the thread, the two discuss a US customer account with problems. Fuller says it was approved by one member of the China team and one member of the US team. Talking about the Customer Identification Program (the US rule that brokers must check who is really opening an account), Fuller suggests the team tends to approve everyone anyway. Wang answers with a Chinese phrase that translates roughly as "exists in name only."
This follows the committee's October 7 report, which argued that Webull is tied to China's government in ways that make it a national security risk. Webull shares fell more than 19% after that report.
Webull did not directly answer CNBC's questions about Wang's access. It said US customer data is stored only on Amazon Web Services servers in Virginia and Oregon, that only US-based staff can reach sensitive data, and that nobody outside the US has ever run its US brokerage. It added that the messages came from a routine 2021 matter with FINRA, the industry's self-regulator, that has been closed, and questioned the timing of their release.
Why it matters
For a broker, trust is the product. The committee says its point is not where data is stored but who can reach it and the systems that process it. It also says a Webull affiliate once used Tencent Cloud, a Chinese provider, to host some user data, and that Webull has not said what data or when that stopped.
The stock was already under pressure before all this. According to Noorult data, Webull closed at $5.90 on October 19, down about 46% over the past year. Its 2025 filings show revenue of about $571 million and net income of about $25 million.
What to watch
- Whether the committee's findings lead to action by regulators or other lawmakers.
- Any fuller answer from Webull on what Tencent Cloud hosted and when that ended.
- The new product push: Webull says it is teaming up with prediction market Kalshi to offer US customers perpetual futures, which never expire, starting with crypto.
Webull's financials are on its Noorult company page.
The companies in this story
Based on reporting by CNBC: House committee says Webull messages point to China access to U.S. customer data. Facts, not advice.
More news
- Anthropic's IPO, in numbers: 825 million shares at $70 to $78, and a $1.4 trillion price tag
- Trump says the Nvidia scandal didn't endanger US security, and stands by Lutnick
- Nvidia's first earnings without Huang: what Kress will be asked on Tuesday
- Buffett gives away $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock in his Thanksgiving letter
- Banks are using AI to trim back offices. Proof that it adds revenue is harder to find
- IMF chief says the world economy leans too hard on AI as circular deals top $1 trillion